In this article of Legal Speak 101, we talk about the term “disposed” in reference to a case. Have you checked on the status of your case and found that it was disposed? Here’s what it means and what you should do next.
What Does “Case Disposed” Mean?
If your case status says that your case has been disposed, it means that the proceedings of your case have been completed, a final order is issued, and the trial has ended. Another way of saying this is if a case has been “junked” or “dismissed.”
In a civil court, a case is disposed after all the charges in the case have been dealt with and the decision has been given. Once a civil case has been disposed, the party that has lost the case can either appeal to a higher court for a chance at a different result, or accept the decision and stop pursuing the case.
The best current example for this was the 2018 ruling of the Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission. The Supreme Court gave a ruling in 2018 that the owner of Masterpiece Cakeshop could not be forced to make a wedding cake for a same-sex couple, but the earliest case goes back in 2012. In 2012, the couple had filed a lawsuit against the cakeshop, and the court ruled in their favor. The cakeshop owner, however appealed to the Court of Appeals and still lost. So, the owner petitioned to the Supreme Court, which ultimately overturned the original decision.
In a criminal case, however, a case is considered disposed if the accused has been acquitted of all charges, the accused has been convicted and sentenced, the prosecution drops all charges, or if the judges believes there is not enough evidence to warrant a trial.
Understanding the Process of Case Disposition
The process of case disposition starts with a motion to dismiss. The court can either grant or deny the motion. If granted, the case can be disposed, and the trial concluded. If it is denied, then the court will allow a hearing. Both parties can present evidence and witnesses to support their case during the hearing.
At the end of the hearing, the court will make a ruling based on the facts presented. This ruling is called a “judgment,” and it can be for the plaintiff or defendant. Once a judgment has been made, the case is disposed of and cannot be reheard. This is why it is important to understand the meaning of “case disposed” in civil court proceedings.
Disposed vs. Disposition
A case disposed is different from a case disposition. A case disposed generally refers to a case that has been completed. A disposition, however, refers to the different ways how a case could be resolved.
Case dispositions include conviction (the accused is sentenced), acquittal (the accused is declared not guilty by the judge or jury), dismissal (there’s not enough evidence to say that there is an actual crime.
A disposition is different from a verdict. The latter finds the accused either not guilty or guilty of a crime. However, a disposition can indicate whether the verdict points to a guilty or not guilty verdict.
Common Outcomes of a Disposed Case
Different outcomes can be expected when a case is disposed, depending on the type of case. Here are some expected outcomes that could result from a case being disposed:
Dismissal With Prejudice
If the judge decides that there is insufficient evidence to warrant a trial, they may dismiss the case with prejudice. The prosecution can return the case to court if new evidence proves the defendant committed a crime. This is also known as “case remanded.”
Dismissal Without Prejudice
This type of dismissal means that if new evidence proves guilt, the prosecution will not be allowed to bring the case back to court. This type of dismissal occurs when the current prosecution lacks evidence to prove that a crime has been committed.
In civil cases, judgments are the most common outcome of a case disposed. The judge on the case will issue a ruling based on the facts presented in the trial. This ruling will either be for the plaintiff (the party filing a suit) or the defendant (the person being sued).
A Guilty Plea
In criminal cases, the accused can plead guilty to the charges brought against them. Pleading guilty means the defendant admits to committing a crime and accepts the associated punishment. In some cases, pleading guilty can allow for reduced charges or a shorter sentence.
A Guilty Verdict
If the accused does not plead guilty, a trial will occur. In this instance, the jury or judge will decide based on the facts presented. If they find the accused guilty, then a guilty verdict will be issued, and the accused will face whatever punishment associated with their crime.
If the jury or judge finds insufficient evidence to prove guilt, a “not guilty” verdict will be issued. This means that the accused is cleared of all charges brought against them and allowed to go free.
What’s Next After a Case is Disposed?
Depending on the case’s outcome, there could be various next steps.
If the accused was found not guilty or the charges were dropped, they may be able to expunge (remove) any evidence associated with the case from their criminal record. This will help them in the future if they need to apply for jobs or have any other background checks done.
In some cases, the records may be sealed rather than expunged. This means the records are still accessible but only to specific people or organizations. This is usually done if the accused was found guilty and the judge believes they have been rehabilitated and served their sentence.
Reducing a Felony
Sometimes, the court may reduce a felony charge to a misdemeanor. This means the accused would face fewer penalties but still have the conviction on their record. This is usually done in cases where the defendant has admitted to their crime and shown remorse.
Importance and Impact of Case Disposition
Understanding what a “case disposed” means can help you better comprehend your legal situation and the steps that must be taken afterward. This is because the court’s decision will affect your rights and obligations.
For instance, if the court finds you guilty of a crime, you may be required to pay a certain fine or serve a prison sentence. On the other hand, if your case is dismissed, you may still be able to pursue legal action against another party for damages. Understanding the various outcomes of a case disposed helps you prepare for what may come next in your legal case.
What Happens If I Don’t Appeal?
Let’s say that you have a case and it did not turn out in your favor. Should you not appeal within the given time limit, then the ruling stays unless enough significant evidence rises to overturn the decision. This makes the case a disposed case.
If you feel that there is a higher chance of the decision being overturned, you can opt to appeal to a higher court. You must do this within the given time limit, so you must act as soon as possible. Consult with your lawyer about possible options before your case is disposed.
Can a Lawyer Help You?
A lawyer isn’t required in a trial (you can choose to represent yourself in a court of law), but it’s highly recommended that you have one. Depending on what the case is, you have to find a lawyer within that field to best represent you legally. Lawyers usually specialize in one or two fields of law, so if you have a criminal case, it’s best to get a criminal lawyer. How long a trial lasts also depends on what the case is.
While you are allowed to represent yourself in court, it’s highly discouraged especially if you don’t have any legal experience. If you can’t find a lawyer, one will be provided for you. You can also look for lawyers willing to handle your case pro bono.
Lawyers have spent years studying the law, and you can find lawyers in the field who have handled cases similar to yours. A lawyer can spot signs that a criminal case is weak and has experience challenging evidence better than you can. If your case is high-stakes and you’re prone to emotional, it’s best to have a detached, objective, and legal-savvy lawyer on your side.
To recap, a disposed case is a case that has already reached a decision. The disposition of the case, on the other hand, can vary depending on what the judge decides in court. If your case was disposed but not in your favor, you still have the option of taking your case to a higher court for a chance to overturn the result. However, you need to do this within a certain window period before the ruling is declared final. Should you choose not to act within this window, the result remains and the case is officially disposed.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens after a case is disposed?
The case outcome will depend on what type of case it is. Generally, outcomes can include dismissal without or with prejudice, a judgment for the plaintiff or defendant, a guilty plea, and a not guilty verdict.
Can a disposed case be reopened?
Sometimes, a dismissed case may be reopened if new evidence proves the defendant has committed a crime. However, this will depend on the type of dismissal that was issued. If a case is dismissed without prejudice, it cannot be reopened.
Can a disposed case appear on a criminal record?
The case will be on their criminal record if the accused is found guilty. If they were acquitted or the charges were dropped, they may be able to expunge or seal the record so it does not appear on a background check.
How long does the case disposition process take?
The length of the process will depend on the type of case and how complicated it is. Generally, criminal and civil cases can take several months to a few years to resolve. In some cases, the process may be expedited, depending on the severity of the case.
Now that you know what “case disposed” means, it’s essential to understand the implications of this terminology and how it will affect your legal situation. Understanding what “case disposed” means in different contexts can help you better understand the outcome of your case and help you prepare for any potential legal action that may follow. Finally, always consult a lawyer if you have any doubts or questions about your case.
What other legal terms do you want us to explain in layman terms? Send us a message or comment your questions and terms below!